Movieland Mystery Photo

    
June 14, 2010, Mystery Photo
Los Angeles Times file photo 

  As nearly everyone realized, this is Evelyn Nesbit, the subject of a recent Paul Coates column
Just a reminder on how this works: I post the mystery photo on Monday and reveal the answer on Friday … or on Saturday if I have a hard time picking only five pictures; sometimes it's difficult to choose. To keep the mystery photo from getting lost in the other entries, I move it from Monday to Tuesday to Wednesday, etc., adding a photo every day.

I have to approve all comments, so if your guess is posted immediately, that means you're wrong. (And if a wrong guess has already been submitted by someone else, there's no point in submitting it again).

If you're right, you will have to wait until Friday. There's no need to submit your guess five times. Once is enough. The only reward is bragging rights. 

The answer to last week's mystery star is Madge Bellamy!

There’s another photo on the jump!


  June 15, 2010, Mystery Photo
Los Angeles Times file photo

Update: This is Evelyn Nesbit and ex-husband Jack Clifford in a photo marked June 24, 1917.

Here’s Tuesday’s photo of our mystery guest with a mystery companion. And it turns out she’s not much of a mystery. Nearly everybody has identified her! Please congratulate Steve Stoliar, CatM, Mary Mallory, Evelyn, Eve Golden, Anne Papineau, Mark Heimback-Nielsen, Mike Hawks, Gregory Moore, Arye Michael Bender, Virginia Hollender, Benito, Virginia Jauregui, Jenny M, Ronald Emmis, Sarah, Anna, Sue, Pete Nowell and Dennis Gilliam.

June 16, 2010, Mystery Photo 
Los Angeles Times file photo

Update: Evelyn Nesbit and former husband Harry K. Thaw in a photo marked June 9, 1926.

For Wednesday, we have our mystery guest with a mystery companion. Please congratulate Stacia, Claire Lockhart, Pamela Porter and Dewey Webb for identifying her and congratulate Mary Mallory and Sarah for identifying Tuesday's mystery companion.

June 17, 2010, Mystery Photo
Los Angeles Times file photo

Update: Evelyn Nesbit and Joan Collins on the set of "The Girl in the Red Velvet Swing" in a photo marked July 24, 1955. "Miss Nesbit is confined to Hollywood Presbyterian Hospital suffering from severe gastric attack," according to the caption information.

And for Thursday, our mystery guest has a mystery companion – although I suppose just about everyone is going to identify this picture. I’m pleased that the Daily Mirror has such literate readers! Please congratulate Mark, Randy Skretvedt, La Peregrina, Patricia van Hartesveldt and Carol Gwenn for identifying her. And congratulate Gregory Moore and Randy Skretvedt for identifying Wednesday's mystery companion.

June 18, 2010, Mystery Photo
Photograph by Ed Lundberg / Los Angeles Times

Update: Evelyn Nesbit is "shown working over bust she created. She has booth at the ceramics show at Long Beach Municipal Auditorium," according to the caption information, dated July 30, 1954.

For Friday, here’s our mystery guest with some of her artwork! Please congratulate Julie Merholz, Cold in PHX and Rick Scott for identifying our mystery woman. And congratulate Mary Mallory, Carol Gwenn, Mike Hawks, Arye Michael Bender,  Steven Moshlak and Randy Skretvedt  for identifying her mystery companion.

June 21, 2010, Mystery Photo
Photograph by George R. Fry / Los Angeles Times

The sparsely attended funeral of Evelyn Nesbit at St. Martin of Tours Catholic Church in Brentwood, Jan. 20, 1967.

Unknown's avatar

About lmharnisch

I am retired from the Los Angeles Times
This entry was posted in Film, Hollywood, Mystery Photo, Photography. Bookmark the permalink.

66 Responses to Movieland Mystery Photo

  1. Steve Stoliar's avatar Steve Stoliar says:

    Is it Evelyn Nesbit?

    Like

  2. Anne Papineau's avatar Anne Papineau says:

    Elizabeth McGovern?

    Like

  3. CatM's avatar CatM says:

    Evelyn Nesbit?

    Like

  4. Mary Mallory's avatar Mary Mallory says:

    Evelyn Nesbit-Thaw?

    Like

  5. fibber mcgee's avatar fibber mcgee says:

    Well, the tiger’s name is Larry….

    Like

  6. evelyn's avatar evelyn says:

    evelyn nesbit

    Like

  7. Eve's avatar Eve says:

    Ah! The delectible Evelyn Nesbit, with one “t!”

    Like

  8. Anne Papineau's avatar Anne Papineau says:

    She looks just like Evelyn Nesbit but that seems too easy.

    Like

  9. Is it Evelyn Nesbit?

    Like

  10. Barbara Klein's avatar Barbara Klein says:

    Jane Novak

    Like

  11. william's avatar william says:

    Claudia Cardinale

    Like

  12. Mike Hawks's avatar Mike Hawks says:

    The lady looks like Evelyn Nesbit.

    Like

  13. benito's avatar benito says:

    Barbara LaMarr?

    Like

  14. Gregory Moore's avatar Gregory Moore says:

    Evelyn Nesbittt?

    Like

  15. Anne Papineau's avatar Anne Papineau says:

    Joan Collins portrayed Eveyln in the Girl in the Red Velvet Swing.
    Is it a retro-styled Joan??

    Like

  16. Gerald McCann's avatar Gerald McCann says:

    Helen Hayes!

    Like

  17. Arye Michael Bender's avatar Arye Michael Bender says:

    She’s the girl in the red velvet swing, Evelyn Nesbit. Have no idea who the tiger is.
    And there’s no truth in the rumor that she was seeing Ray Milland. He would have been way to young for her.

    Like

  18. Diane Ely's avatar Diane Ely says:

    Adrienne Barbeau?

    Like

  19. Virginia Hollender's avatar Virginia Hollender says:

    Evelyn Nesbitt

    Like

  20. benito's avatar benito says:

    Evelyn Nesbit Thaw. She was tough but her kimono and the rug gave her away. Joan Collins played her in The Girl on the Red Velvet Swing, shown recently on cable.

    Like

  21. virginia jauregui's avatar virginia jauregui says:

    Is it Evelyn Nesbitt?

    Like

  22. Jenny M's avatar Jenny M says:

    Evelyn Nesbit

    Like

  23. Ronald Emmis's avatar Ronald Emmis says:

    Hey, folks, that can be only one woman:
    Evelyn Nesbit, the “girl in the red swing.”
    Her lover, Harry K. Thaw, shot Stanford White over her. And he almost completely got away with the killing.
    Ronald Emmis

    Like

  24. RJ's avatar RJ says:

    Valerie Allen ?

    Like

  25. Sarah's avatar Sarah says:

    Evelyn Nesbit!

    Like

  26. Rinky Dink's avatar Rinky Dink says:

    Isadora Duncan?

    Like

  27. Anna's avatar Anna says:

    Evelyn Nesbit (Thaw)?

    Like

  28. Sue's avatar Sue says:

    evelyn nesbit

    Like

  29. Greg Clancey's avatar Greg Clancey says:

    Posing on that tiger, she reminds me of Barbara Feldon (Rrrrrrrrrow!)

    Like

  30. pete nowell's avatar pete nowell says:

    evelyn nesbit…damn i might have shot sanford white too

    Like

  31. Evelyn Nesbit Shaw

    Like

  32. Oops ! I meant Evelyn Nesbit Thaw

    Like

  33. sharon's avatar sharon says:

    Theda Bara?

    Like

  34. Dewey Webb's avatar Dewey Webb says:

    Evelyn Nesbit

    Like

  35. Arye Michael Bender's avatar Arye Michael Bender says:

    Is her Tuesday presenter Charles Gibson? Before ‘Good Morning America’, of course.

    Like

  36. Pamela Porter's avatar Pamela Porter says:

    Evelyn Nesbit

    Like

  37. Sarah's avatar Sarah says:

    The mystery companion is Jack Clifford.

    Like

  38. Mary Mallory's avatar Mary Mallory says:

    Is this her dancing partner Jack Clifford?

    Like

  39. Claire Lockhart's avatar Claire Lockhart says:

    Evelyn Nesbit

    Like

  40. Stacia's avatar Stacia says:

    Evelyn Nesbit. I hope.
    (I’m still stinging from not checking on last week’s early enough to guess, because I knew that one for once!)

    Like

  41. Carol Gwenn's avatar Carol Gwenn says:

    Ooohhh! Evelyn Nesbit, the girl on the velvet swing!

    Like

  42. Gregory Moore's avatar Gregory Moore says:

    Harry K. Thaw?

    Like

  43. I note that the first of the incorrect answers, listed in the comments for the Movieland Mystery photo, was Elizabeth McGovern, who actually played the mystery star in a movie.

    Like

  44. Julie Merholz's avatar Julie Merholz says:

    Coco Chanel

    Like

  45. Patricia van Hartesveldt's avatar Patricia van Hartesveldt says:

    Evelyn Nesbit.

    Like

  46. Patty's avatar Patty says:

    Fanny Brice?

    Like

  47. la peregrina's avatar la peregrina says:

    Why that is Evelyn Nesbit, the girl in the red velvet swing. Paula Uruburu has written a great book about her and “the crime of the century” called AMERICAN EVE.

    Like

  48. Randy Skretvedt's avatar Randy Skretvedt says:

    Ah, it’s Evelyn Nesbit, and I believe the gent with her in Wednesday’s photo is her former husband, Harry Kendall Thaw. Is the fellow with her in Tuesday’s photo Jack Clifford, her one-time dancing partner (and also former husband)?

    Like

  49. Mark's avatar Mark says:

    Evelyn Nesbit

    Like

  50. Mary Mallory's avatar Mary Mallory says:

    Here EN is with Joan Collins, who played her in the movie THE GIRL IN THE RED VELVET SWING.

    Like

  51. Dewey Webb's avatar Dewey Webb says:

    Aldous Huxley

    Like

  52. Carol Gwenn's avatar Carol Gwenn says:

    It’s amazing how much the young JOAN COLLINS looks like Elizabeth Taylor at around the same age. Does anyone know:
    is “The Girl in the Red Velvet Swing” available on DVD?

    Like

  53. Mike Hawks's avatar Mike Hawks says:

    Gee, could that be Joan Collins with our lady.

    Like

  54. Arye Michael Bender's avatar Arye Michael Bender says:

    Wow! Today’s pic: The real and the surreal, side by side.
    It is on the set of ‘The Girl on the Red Velvet Swing’ where the real Evelyn Nesbit coaches the Fake Evelyn Nesbit – Joan Collins – on how to be Evelyn Nesbit.
    Amazing.

    Like

  55. Julie Merholz's avatar Julie Merholz says:

    Evelyn Nesbit

    Like

  56. Cold in PHX's avatar Cold in PHX says:

    Oh, this is Evelyn Nesbit, and the photo is with Joan Collins from the set of “The Girl in the Red Velvet Swing.” I thought that first picture was familiar for some reason.

    Like

  57. One of the companions is the beautiful Joan Collins.

    Like

  58. Cornelia Otis Skinner?

    Like

  59. Randy Skretvedt's avatar Randy Skretvedt says:

    The Thursday picture is Evelyn Nesbit with Joan Collins, who portrayed Evelyn in the 1955 movie “The Girl in the Red Velvet Swing.” Looks like they’re perusing the script. Also looks like Joan is wondering if she’ll look like Evelyn in 40 more years (she didn’t!).

    Like

  60. Rick Scott's avatar Rick Scott says:

    Late to the game….Evelyn Nesbitt.

    Like

  61. fibber mcgee's avatar fibber mcgee says:

    I’m just a poor country boy in the Big City and try as I might, I cannot see where you identify your mystery person. You seem to think everyone on the planet — has Osama Bin Laden e-mailed you with a guess? — knows her name but why not give a break to the unfortunates out there? Not everybody saw the old movie, after all. You identified mostly the Usual Suspects as guessing right but I think perhaps you have a lot more readers. I hope so.

    Like

  62. Suzy Q's avatar Suzy Q says:

    Better late than never – Evelyn Nesbit.

    Like

  63. Chuck's avatar Chuck says:

    I recognize Joan Collins from Thursday, but I have no idea who the Mystery Guest is. I’m just shocked the Times ran a picture with nipples showing!

    Like

  64. Rinky Dink's avatar Rinky Dink says:

    Evelyn Nesbit?

    Like

  65. Megan's avatar Megan says:

    When looking at these pictures, I am surprised that Evelyn Nesbit was the physical inspiration for Anne of Green Gables.

    Like

  66. CatM's avatar CatM says:

    I remember hearing about her exhibit, and that her dream at the time was to create a life sized sculpture of Marilyn Monroe, because she had such a lovely figure. What a marvelous historic mashup that would have been. I wonder what happened to her artwork? That one on display is really very good. And what a sad funeral…but for the longest time, she wanted people to forget who she was. I guess she got that in the end.
    Until now, of course.

    Like

Comments are closed.