In Cred I Ble

The sale of 1940s mug shots, including one of Elizabeth Short, sold Jan. 12, 2007, for $1,802.77 (more than $78 per picture) to phenomaly. Although EBay now conceals bidders’ identities, we can see that the next highest bid was $1,777.77. Obviously, people are willing to spend serious money for these mug shots.

Please understand, the Elizabeth Short mug shots were printed up in bulk during the investigation and handed out freely. The mug shot was also distributed by the wire services. Translation: There were many copies of this picture. Think carefully before getting into a bidding war over one of them. They turn upon EBay every couple of years.

About lmharnisch

I am retired from the Los Angeles Times
This entry was posted in 1947, Black Dahlia, Books and Authors, Cold Cases, Crime and Courts, Homicide, LAPD, Uncategorized and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to In Cred I Ble

  1. Anonymous says:

    Whoever this phenomaly is sure must be crazy to spend that much money on a photo. But I guess in a way it shows how passionately dedicated someone can be to preserve certain elements related to this case…sometimes no matter the cost. It’s not very practical for sure, but I somewhat admire the sacrifice.


  2. Larry says:

    You raise a good point in some ways. I will always applaud preservation for historians’ purposes. And if these items were to be donated to an archive or library (or the LAPD Historical Society, for that matter), I would be the first to congratulate the buyer.

    All too often, however, these–and far more ghoulish items from this case–vanish into private hands and are treated like macabre baseball cards or some other gruesome trophies, acquired at great expense and gloated over in secret.

    That’s my objection.

    And in case you are wondering, once I’m done with the Elizabeth Short case I plan to donate absolutely everything to an archive. I will never put any of it on the open market.

    Larry Harnisch

    ps. and that is still way too much money for something that is relatively common.


  3. Anonymous says:

    Apparently the seller sent along this info about the original owner of the photos:“The mug shots belonged to a Captain Kearney of the Downtown beat LAPD. He had working directly under him detectives Mott and Pena. They were right there on the spot in 1947. From the other mugs it would appear that these guys were working mostly with murder and mob related cases. I guess downtown LA in the 40’s was a pretty busy and a pretty sleazy place with servicemen traveling through, and with Chicago gangsters trying to set up shop in LA. The bus station and train depot were right near by, and crime and murder was rampant. The Downtown LAPD was also ripe with corruption, and these guys seem to have been right in the middle of all of it. In 1943 Kearney was a Lieutenant, and by 1944 was bumped up to a Captain.In 1954 Kearney was a script consultant on at least one episode of Dragnet, which had a working title of “the big Mailman”, which I got a working copy of. I don’t know weather the show was ever aired.Kearney retired in the late 50’s.”


  4. Larry says:

    You are somewhat (but only somewhat) correct. Capt. Francis J. Kearney joined the LAPD in 1926. He was transferred from heading narcotics to heading homicide after Jack Donahoe was moved to robbery in September 1947. He was transferred to the narcotics squad in 1951 and retired in 1952. All those other claims about the LAPD being rife with corruption in the late 1940s (postwar period) is nonsense. I’m proud to say I know a fair number of retirees from this time period and they are a fine bunch of men, very honest and service-minded. Cheers,Larry


  5. Anonymous says:

    Hey, don’t shoot the messenger. 🙂I’m glad for the clarification though.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.