
This week’s mystery movie was the 1928 Universal film Lonesome, with Glenn Tryon, Barbara Kent, Fay Holderness, Gustav Partos and Eddie Phillips.
Adaptation and scenario by Edward T. Lowe Jr.
Dialogue and titles by Tom Reed.
Photographed by Gilbert Warrenton.
Edited by Frank Atkinson.
Directed by Paul Fejos.
Further information on Lonesome is available from the AFI Catalog.
Lonesome is available on Blu-ray from Critics’ Choice Video.
::
After striking out last week in my search for films set at Coney Island, I found Lonesome, which features some sequences of Coney Island, plus more footage from Ocean Park. It is “sound on film” with a musical score and sound effects, but only brief bits of spoken dialogue, which were added later. As Sylvia pointed out, Lonesome was added to the Library of Congress National Film Registry in 2010. Raquel Stecher’s essay is here in pdf format.
Now that summer is over, our fling with films about amusement parks (and roller coasters) must come to an end. It’s time to look elsewhere. And where shall we go next? That’s to be decided!
This is fairly early for a New York Times review. I’m guessing Mordaunt Hall?
We are firmly in Mordaunt Hall territory and he does not care for Lonesome (October 2, 1928):
Dr. Paul Fejos, producer of that unusual film The Last Moment, is responsible for Lonesome, the production with which Universal has re-opened the Colony Theatre. This current attraction suggests an O. Henry story without that author’s keen insight into human nature. It is agreeable and interesting, a relief in many respects from the cut and dried picture formula so frequently set forth as a narrative. But there are a number of episodes where Dr. Fejos’s imagination seems stunted. Sometimes it looks as though he did not know what to do with his characters; he also sounds the same note too often.
The rigid direction has its effect upon the acting, particularly on the performance of Barbara Kent, who charming as she looks when smiling, is hardly expected to appear as cheerful as she does in most of the scenes.
The prolonging of some sequences, the culmination of which is by no means surprising, does not add to the strength of this effort and hoped-for ideas fail to flame forth. It is a story that could have been pictured with more fervency, truth and originality. Dr. Fejos’s fancy of taking his characters to Coney Island does not help his narrative, for with all his knowledge of camera tricks the scenes of that popular resort are not very different from those beheld in countless other pictures.

For Monday, we have a mysterious switchboard operator and an enigmatic caller.
Update: This is Mrs. Louise Emmons with Barbara Kent as Back of the Head Woman.

For “Tricky Tuesday,” we have still another mysterious amusement park (several mystery amusement parks appear in our mysterious movie).
Update: This is Dragons Gorge at Coney Island.
Brain Trust roll call: Anne Papineau (mystery movie, Monday’s mystery caller and Back of the Head Woman), Sylvia (mystery movie, Monday’s mysterious caller and Back of the Head Woman), Mike Hawks (mystery movie, Monday’s mystery caller and Back of the Head Woman), Allie (mystery movie and Monday’s mysterious caller) and L.C. (mystery movie, mysterious cast and one mystery amusement parks).
A historic image of Dragons Gorge, Shelby White and Leon Levy Digital Library.
![]()
For comparison, Dragon Gorge at Ocean Park.
![]()
And Dragon Gorge at Revere Beach, Mass.

For “Hm Wednesday,” we have a mysterious fellow. The leading man has been cropped out because of insufficient mysteriousness and will appear Friday.
Update: Adding our mysterious leading man.
Update: This is Andy Devine, left, and Glenn Tryon.
Brain Trust roll call: Anne Papineau (mysterious roller coaster and amusement park), Chrisbo (Monday’s mystery woman), Stacia (mysterious roller coaster and amusement park), Roget-L.A. (mysterious roller coaster and amusement park, but another movie) and Sylvia (mysterious roller coaster and amusement park, mystery camera techniques).

For “Aha Thursday,” we have this mysterious masher.
Update: This is Eddie Phillips and Barbara Kent half out of the frame.

And we have a mysterious woman. The leading lady has been cropped out and will appear tomorrow.
Update: Adding mysterious leading lady.
Update: This is Barbara Kent, center, and Fay Holderness.
Brain Trust roll call: Megan and Thom (Wednesday’s mysterious guest), Stacia (mystery movie and Wednesday’s mystery guest), Chrisbo (mystery movie and Man Cropped Out Because of Lack of Mysteriousness), Roget-L.A. (mystery movie, Monday’s mysterious caller and Back of the Head Woman and Wednesday’s mysterious fellow), B.J. Merholz (Wednesday’s mystery guest), and Sylvia E. (Wednesday’s mystery guest).

For Friday, we have our mysterious leads in color – with spoken dialogue!
Update: This is Barbara Kent and Glenn Tryon.
Brain Trust roll call: Eve Golden (Monday’s mysterious caller), Anne Papineau (Wednesday’s mysterious future TV actor and Thursday’s mystery guests), (Sylvia (Wednesday’s mysteriously cropped out leading man and Thursday’s mysterious guests and cropped-out leading lady) and Mike Hawks (Thursday’s mystery guests).

The haunting face of Louise Emmons in “Lonesome,” with Barbara Kent as the telephone operator.
LikeLike
Lonesome 1928
Monday – Mrs Louise Emmons is the caller and Barbara Kent is the BOTHW.
Would never have had a guess without Mrs Emmons
LikeLike
Mrs. Louise Emmons and Barbara Kent in LONESOME.
LikeLike
It’s our Louise Emmons!
LikeLike
Lonesome (1928)
LikeLike
Lonesome (1928) w/ Barbara Kent, Glenn Tryon, Fay Holderness, Eddie Phillips, Andy Devine, Henry Armetta, Gusztav Partos, Louise Emmons, Fred Esmelton, Coney Island and Ocean Park at Santa Monica Pier.
LikeLike
Luna Park at Coney Island, Brooklyn, New York
LikeLike
Is that Louise Emmons on Monday?
LikeLike
Tuesday is Dragon’s Gorge at Coney Island, absolutely gorgeous. Destroyed by fire in 1944! This looks like a tinted silent but I’m not finding anything that matches this description, have a couple of really early talkies to check out though.
LikeLike
For Tricky Tuesday, we have Dragons Gorge at Coney Island’s Luna Park in “The Crowd” (1928)
LikeLike
Tuesday – if this is stock footage, it probably is actually Coney Island, hand colored and restored by the Eastman Museum. I think it may be, because I don’t recall seeing “Dragon’s Gorge” at the Long Beach Pike, where some of the amusement park scenes were shot, along with Universal backlot sets. It’s been interesting to read about the camera innovations done in this film and Paul Fejos, Leon Shamroy and Carl Laemmle Jr’s involvement.
LikeLike
Today’s guest is Andy Devine, still wet behind the ears.
LikeLike
This is LONESOME (1928), just found it last night! Wednesday must be a young Andy Devine!
LikeLike
Glenn Tyson in Lonesome?
LikeLike
For “Hm Wednesday”, we have Andy Devine in Lonesome (1928). Louise Emmons as Monday’s enigmatic caller, and Barbara Kent as Monday’s mysterious switchboard operator.
LikeLike
A younger, thinner Andy Devine.
LikeLike
Wednesday – a VERY young Andy Devine
LikeLike
Never dreamt I’d see such a young Andy Devine (and later Henry Armetta as well). Not sure if bow tie guy is Eddie Phillips or someone else. And is that Fay Holderness at the last?
LikeLike
I thought I had sent in Wednesday’s cropped guy earlier after I sent in Mr Devine, but I guess I didn’t. I’m pretty sure it’s Glenn Tryon.
Anyhoo – Thursday
I think our lady is Fay Holderness, with Barbara Kent cropped out.
Not sure of the guy, but I’ll guess he’s Eddie Nelson Phillips
LikeLike
Too Much Johnson?
LikeLike
An excellent guess! But not quite right….
LikeLike
Fay Holderness and Eddie Phillips.
LikeLike
Barbara and Glenn.
LikeLike
Barbara Kent and Glenn Tryon
LikeLike