Eve Golden’s YouTube Theater: Talking About Talkies


A program for “The Jazz Singer” at Chicago’s Garrick Theatre (d. 1960), listed on EBay at $141.53.

If you tell me that The Jazz Singer was “the first talkie,” I will have to punch you in the throat. I know you won’t take it personally, but anyone who thinks that The Jazz Singer was the first talkie just needs to be punched in the throat. I mean, for goodness sake, two years before The Jazz Singer, Theodore Case had already made the greatest talkie in the world, featuring Gus Visser and His Singing Duck [checks carefully that I spelled “Duck” right):


“Talkies” existed back in the late 1890s, using a combination of films and records played sort of simultaneously. There were lots of problems with that, of course, the “simultaneously” being one. If the record or the film was a half-second too fast or too slow, the whole effect was ruined. And projecting the sound of a record throughout a theater—even a small one—was beyond early technology (even today, miked Broadway shows are sometimes unintelligible).

So the earliest talkies we see on YouTube today are of a much higher quality than the original audiences enjoyed! Here we have opera star Jean Noté singing “La Marseillaise” in 1907:

Remember, the Reign of Terror took place in 1793-4, and Jean Noté was born in 1858—he certainly must have met people who remembered the French Revolution first-hand.

And here, the high-camp music-hall star Félix Mayol sings “La Polka des Trottins,” in 1905:

Maurice Chevalier started his career as a Mayol impersonator; Mayol had been a star since 1895, and continued performing into the 1930s. The director of this snippet was Alice Guy, who made her first film in 1896 and was certainly the pioneering female filmmaker—she was head of production at the Gaumont Film Company from 1896-1906.

So remember—do not go around saying talkies started in 1927, if you are within punching distance of me.

About lmharnisch

I am retired from the Los Angeles Times
This entry was posted in Eve Golden, Film, Hollywood and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Eve Golden’s YouTube Theater: Talking About Talkies

  1. betty1114 says:

    Learn something new today Eve, excellent!


  2. aryedirect says:

    The Japanese version was, ‘If You Knew Sushi’. It was kinda fishy.


  3. donnalethal says:

    I was waiting for the column where Gus Visser would make his appearance! Bravo.


  4. Lee Rivas says:

    My understanding of the term “talkie” includes talking and not just singing. (That would be a “singie.”) While “The Jazz Singer” contained barely two minutes worth of synchronized talking, it was talking nonetheless and so it qualifies…..


  5. Howard Decker says:

    Early audiences, many of them European immigrants, did not want talkies. They could fugure out the plot much easier with silent films. Their kids grew up learning English in Americn schools and wanted talkes when they came of age.


Leave a Reply. Note: Your IP is logged with your comment so a fake name and email address are useless.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s