George ‘Evil Genius’ Hodel and the Black Dahlia – Another Good Story Ruined


Look who fell for the fake Daily News front page. Yes, it’s a fake.

There are about a thousand things I would prefer to do besides shoot holes in the latest installment of the Dr. George “Evil Genius” Hodel franchise. But I heard from a friend last night that KNBC-TV Channel 4 had aired a segment about the Black Dahlia case. I missed it (thank heavens) but it’s on the website. And the whole thing reminds me of poor old crazy Janice Knowlton (RIP), who insisted that her father, George, killed the Black Dahlia.

I wouldn’t recommend that anyone actually watch the segment, because you’ll just have to “unlearn” the mistakes but basically it rehashes the “Black Dahlia Avenger” books and insists that the Evil Genius killed the Black Dahlia in the basement of his house at 5121 Franklin Ave.

You may recall the previous “evidence” used to link the Evil Genius to the Black Dahlia case: photographs found in his belongings after his death that showed Elizabeth Short. Only, no, they weren’t of Elizabeth Short at all. Oops.

In reality, there is nothing to establish that the Evil Genius and Elizabeth Short – nicknamed the Black Dahlia – ever met. Zero. Nada. Zilch.

It is true that Dr. George Hodel was a suspect for a couple of weeks. This may sound more convincing than it actually is because there were hundreds of them; the investigators treated everybody who knew her as a suspect. And no, there’s nothing to show that they ever met, but the police also looked at anyone with any sort of  medical background (no, Dr. George Hodel was not a surgeon) who had anything in their past that involved sex charges, like Dr. Patrick S. O’Reilly, a Glendale osteopath who was accused of “mistreating” a telephone operator.

In this case, we have Paul Dostie, a retired police officer, and his cadaver dog Buster exploring the Sowden House in a segment that was taped but not used in a recent “Ghost Hunters” episode.

Now ask yourself:

Where are Elizabeth Short’s remains?
A cemetery in Oakland.

OK, if her remains are buried in Oakland, what can there possibly be to find in the basement of the Sowden House?
Well, she was drained of blood.

Correct. But hasn’t it been established that draining the body of blood required lots of running water – and therefore a drain?
Um. I guess so.

So if the body was cut in half but none it was missing and the blood was washed down the drain with large amounts of water, what is left to find?

Exactly. Another good story ruined.

About lmharnisch

I am retired from the Los Angeles Times
This entry was posted in 1947, Another Good Story Ruined, Architecture, Black Dahlia, Hollywood, LAPD and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to George ‘Evil Genius’ Hodel and the Black Dahlia – Another Good Story Ruined

  1. Don Murphy says:

    Paul Dostie spends his time up at Barker Ranch with his dog telling people that there are many buried bodies up there.
    There aren’t.
    Dostie just needs something to do.


  2. Don Danard says:

    As mentioned once before Larry, YOU really have to write the definitive book on The Dahlia case. Now, that would be a book I would really look forward to reading.


  3. Lee Rivas says:

    It’s funny. I saw the segment and immediately thought of you. I wondered how you would debunk it. I tried too hard and missed the obvious. You simplified it so logically that I realize now, murder investigations are not my forte. Thanks for narrowing my career opportunities.


  4. JAMES says:

    I was so disappointed reading Hodel’s book. I was hoping someone had cracked the case or at least found some new evidence. Instead he pins every unsolved murder in the western hemispere on his father. It’s really sad. He must hate his father so much.


Leave a Reply. Note: Your IP is logged with your comment so a fake name and email address are useless.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s