Another Good Story Ruined — The Battle of Los Angeles

Los Angeles Times file photo

I haven’t talked to a movie publicist since Brian De Palma’s ghastly “The Black Dahlia” came out, but I was recently bombarded with pitches to do some sort of story about the rather comical February 1942 “Battle of Los Angeles” to hype the upcoming science fiction shoot ’em up “Battle: Los Angeles.”

And frankly, if the publicity campaign wanted to establish UFO research as nothing but lies and fakery, it couldn’t have done a better job.

In case you don’t know, every year about this time, someone revisits a rather ridiculous episode of wartime hysteria that occurred shortly after the attack on Pearl Harbor in which more than 1,000 rounds were fired at strange objects in the sky over Los Angeles. The objects were later suspected to be weather balloons – although  nobody was ever really sure. In later years, the reporters who lived through the Battle of Los Angeles treated the whole thing as a big joke. And if the incident sounds familiar, that’s because it inspired the movie “1941.”

ALSO

Battle of Los Angeles on the Daily Mirror 2008

Battle of Los Angeles on the Daily Mirror 2009

The publicists pitching me a story on “Battle: Los Angeles” assured me that the film was about this historic event, which sounded interesting, so I did enough online investigation to discover that there is a cheap knockoff called “Battle of Los Angeles” by those folks who brought you that cinematic triumph “Sharktopus.”   A few minutes with the “Battle: Los Angeles” trailer on YouTube and a scan of the production notes (spoiler: it was filmed in Louisiana) convinced me that the movie is a modern-day shoot ‘em up of Marines vs. aliens, but I was intrigued by the publicity campaign’s attempt to drape the film with some sort of historical authenticity.

And look, I don’t expect accuracy from movies, but here’s what they pulled:

Here’s the actual Times headline from Feb. 26, 1942: “Army Says Alarm Real.”

And here’s the fake headline used in the trailer from – uh-oh – Nov. 6, 1957!


And here’s the actual Times headline … Oh, did they have Sputnik in World War II? Someone better update the entry in Wikipedia!


And how about this supposedly historic photo, shown in a screen grab from the trailer for “Battle: Los Angeles?”


Here’s the photo from ProQuest as published in The Times on Feb. 26, 1942.

These little dots, by the way, were identified in The Times as bursts of anti-aircraft fire illuminated by the spotlights.


Here’s some more fake headlines from the trailer for “Battle: Los Angeles.” Notice that there’s no periods in “L.A.” in the headline “Five Deaths in LA Raid.” Did someone get paid for this?


And here’s the actual headline. Notice that although Bruce Maccabee says in the trailer that five people were killed during the shooting, three died in car accidents during the blackout and two people had heart attacks. Oops.

Ready for more lies? Oh good, here’s another one:


The fake headline says: “Searchlights Reveal Craft Over …”


And the real headline says: “Searchlights and Anti-Aircraft Guns Comb Sky During Alarm.”

Oops.

Nothing but lies and fakery. I don’t know if people who do this sort of work are capable of shame, but it would be nice to think so.

Unknown's avatar

About lmharnisch

I am retired from the Los Angeles Times
This entry was posted in 1942, Another Good Story Ruined, Film, Hollywood, Photography, UFOs. Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to Another Good Story Ruined — The Battle of Los Angeles

  1. Joel's avatar Joel says:

    I’m kind of looking forward to it. I like the stories about the battle of la http://alien-ufo-research.com/battle_of_la/ At least there is a little background to it unlike so many really bad movies made.

    Like

  2. rosie's avatar rosie says:

    One, I don’t think that THE BLACK DAHLIA was a ghastly movie. Two, you were dumb enough to believe that BATTLE: LOS ANGELES was based upon a historic event? Really?

    Like

  3. lrh's avatar lrh says:

    Rosie: That’s what the publicists told me. Why do you think I checked?!

    Like

  4. Fibber McGee's avatar Fibber McGee says:

    There is a phrase in the Spanish language that covers stuff like this. It speaks of being “sin verguenza” — without pride, without shame, without honor.

    Like

  5. Native Angeleno's avatar Native Angeleno says:

    Larry, have you been to the restaurant on the beach in Goleta, The Timbers, constructed with parts of the pier the Japanese sub shelled 2/23/42? If i remember correctly, the inside walls are covered with front page reports of the scare, of which your scroll of front pages reminded me.
    Closest thing we have to the buildings in Gettysburg pitted by shells and bullets.
    The Japanese commander told his superiors he left Santa Barbara in flames. It came out later he attacked Santa Barbara because he fell backward onto a patch of cactus at a cocktail party there once, and everyone laughed.
    Hey, they moved the Rose Bowl to North Carolina 1/1/42 in fear of an attack. (Sneak preview of Daily Mirror 1/1/2012.)

    Like

  6. Sam Flowers's avatar Sam Flowers says:

    In the trailer opening when they show the artillery loading and firing they are using footage of German artillery. I love it when filmdom does not bother to use authentic footage.

    Like

  7. brigade's avatar brigade says:

    “And look, I don’t expect accuracy from movies…”
    but
    “I expect accuracy from movies.” (Paraphrased)

    Like

  8. lrh's avatar lrh says:

    Brigade: I expect something that claims to be “a look at the history behind the films source material with archive footage” to at least make an attempt to be correct, rather than resort to lies and fakery.

    Like

  9. Arye Michael Bender's avatar Arye Michael Bender says:

    Nobody quite does overheated UFO hype the way Bill Birns does. His presence can instantly quash genuine interest in otherwise intriguing exploration. Even he doesn’t believe himself. Watch his hyper eye-blinks. Always more intriguing than his words.

    Like

  10. Kaela's avatar Kaela says:

    The ad for the movie says “based on actual events.” One would think the movie research department would actually, I don’t know, make the dates, photos, etc. consistent.

    Like

  11. Ed's avatar Ed says:

    My father who died a few years ago used to tell me an untold number of war stories when I was a kid. One of his stories was when he was in the coastal artillery stationed in the L.A. area at the beginning of WWII. His story was that the army was getting fed up with civilians ignoring their blackout warnings and finally one night they were ordered to fire a few rounds into the air to shake things up. Well I guess everybody was a little jumpy and things got a bit out of hand. The army was too embarrassed to admit what really happened and they came up with the balloon story.

    Like

Comments are closed.