A miracle

Oct. 5, 1957


The story of Alton Clifton Poret presents unusually frustrating
challenges for the diligent researcher. Identified in a 1954 Times
story as "a former Los Angeles Negro," Poret and Edgar Labat were
sentenced to die in Louisiana’s electric chair for the Nov. 12, 1950,
rape of a white New Orleans telephone operator.

Not that The Times ever said anything so indelicately precise. Indeed,
the paper never ran a word about the original trial and in later
stories merely referred to "a criminal assault charge" or a "criminal
attack of a white woman."

If it weren’t for the efforts of a Westside meat dealer and bail
bondsman, The Times would have written almost nothing about the case.
The advocate was Nelson N. Soll, and he began raising money for Poret’s
defense after reading a Louisiana newspaper article.

"I thought Poret’s story was phony at first," Soll said in a Sept. 14,
1957, story. "Then I checked it out. I’ve spent four years on this
case. I have collected affidavits that prove beyond the shadow of a
doubt that Poret is innocent–that he was not even anywhere near the
scene of the crime. But he is a black man and he is sentenced to die
and only a miracle of the Lord can keep him from being strapped into
that electric chair at one minute past minute next Friday. We are
praying for that miracle."

For his troubles, Soll had a cross burned on the front lawn of his home at 1523 Crest Drive,
The Times said.  Rabbi Abraham  I. Maron of Congregation Mogen David
and the Rev. Leroy M. Kopp  of the United Fundamentalist Church led the
local religious campaign calling for Poret to be spared.

Eventually, the Hollywood Committee for Alton Clifton Poret’s Defense was formed, headed by Adolphe Menjou.
(I guess I’ll have to rethink my opinion of Menjou, which was pretty
low after he praised the Japanese evacuation of Los Angeles during
World War II. To paraphrase, he said he hoped to never see another
Japanese face).

After a long and complex legal battle (the men contended that whites
were systematically excluded from juries) Poret and Labat were released
from prison in 1969, having pleaded guilty to attempted aggravated
assault. At that time, they held the record for being on America’s
death row. Of their 16 years, two months and two days in prison, 14
years had been on death row.

According to the Social Security Death Index, a man named Edgar M.
Labat died in 1998 in Mississippi. Poret disappeared from the pages of
history after being convicted of attempted rape in Rochester, N.Y., in

He wrote this poem in prison:

  Living at the river’s edge,

  Never knowing when they’ll drive that final wedge.

  Will the wheel of justice ever look my way?

  And when it does, what will it have to say?

Nelson N. Soll died in 1994 at the age of 84. His activism did not end
with Poret. He raised money for the defense of a boyhood friend, Jack
Ruby, despite many death threats.

Email me

About lmharnisch

I am retired from the Los Angeles Times
This entry was posted in #courts, Countdown to Watts and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to A miracle

  1. theresa labat mitchell says:

    i am edgar m labat’s daughter theresa he died in mpls. mn it hurts me to read about Poret because i feel that he could have freed my father at any time,


  2. Arlene McCarthy says:

    I too am related to the Labat family. This story is so tragic and painful. The previous comment makes it more painful still.


  3. T.R. says:

    It didnt get me until now……I Miss you Dad !
    From: MPLS
    To: DAD


Leave a Reply. Note: Your IP is logged with your comment so a fake name and email address are useless.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.