Paul V. Coates–Confidential File

Sept. 18, 1957

There are times when justice gets in its own way.

By trying to hustle along a little too fast, it trips over its own ethical skirts.

And a living example of what can happen when it does came into town
last night. He was tall and gaunt and rather ugly, and his prison
pallor contradicted the jaunty cut of his gray flannel suit.

His name–if you’re not aware by now–is Caryl Chessman.

His residence for the last nine years has been San Quentin’s Death Row.

Half a dozen times, dates for his extermination have been set.

But so far, because justice was in an apparent hurry to deal him the
worst, he has outlived some 70 fellow death row inmates, plus the
warden with whom he was in constant strife.

Chessman is here with a claim against justice.

It was, recently, a good enough claim to cause the U.S. Supreme Court
to overrule our state and district courts’ rejections of his latest
appeal for a new trial.

Since his confinement, Chessman–a warped but plainly brilliant
man–has managed to dig up some startling charges about events which
followed his trial and conviction.

The court reporter who took the transcript died during the trial.

His notes, according to later testimony, were considered illegible by
five other court reporters asked to turn them into final transcript.

But then there appeared a man who said he could transcribe them.

His name was Stanley Fraser.

He was given the job and eventually he produced a final transcript.

This, naturally, was important to Chessman. He needed it as a basis for appeals.

But on reading it, he felt that it was inaccurate.

From death row, he began an astonishing investigation.

First, he found, Stanley Fraser was a relative of J. Miller Leavy, prosecutor in the case. He was Leavy’s wife’s uncle.

Then he alleges that he dug up a police record on Fraser which included drunk arrests stringing from July 1948 to February 1951.

Attorney George Davis, representing Chessman, called trial Judge
Charles W. Fricke to the stand at a Marin County hearing last year.

Fricke stated that he had no knowledge of any relationship between Leavy, the prosecutor, and Fraser.

In his latest book, "The Face of Justice" (to be released this week), Chessman makes further charges.

He alleges that Fraser and Leavy held several meetings on the
transcript. He charges that the pair visited two of the prosecution’s
top witnesses for other conferences.

He says that Fraser received three times the normal fee for his work.

If it’s all true, it doesn’t add up to a very fair shake for a man who is doomed without a complete and accurate transcript.

Caryl Chessman is possibly the most widely detested criminal in California history.

He’s not only hated for the horrible nature of his crimes, but for the
smug, self-assured unrepentant attitude he has maintained over the last
nine years.

That same attitude was apparent when I saw him at County Jail yesterday.

He suffers from a chronic sneer aimed at all of society.

Chessman is a weird paradox–a literate, intelligent man, capable of vicious criminal acts.

However, no matter what his attitudes or his crimes, any man is entitled to due process of law.

If he hasn’t been getting it, and the U.S. Supreme Court has indicated that to be true, he should.

About lmharnisch

I am retired from the Los Angeles Times
This entry was posted in #courts, Caryl Chessman, Columnists, Homicide, Paul Coates and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Paul V. Coates–Confidential File

  1. Joe D says:

    Mickey Katz star of Borscht Capades was a member of the Spike Jones Orchestra, he’s featured on the hit Cocktails For Two. He’s also the father of actor Joel Grey.


Leave a Reply. Note: Your IP is logged with your comment so a fake name and email address are useless.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.