In June 1957, about the time she turned 19, Judy, at right, met Betty at a
Hollywood photographer’s studio. They were both young and hoping for
modeling careers, so Betty, 19, asked Judy to move into the apartment
at 1302 N. Sweetzer Ave., which she shared with a third aspiring model, Lynn, 22.
In late July, Judy complained to her roommates that she felt she was
being followed, but assumed it had to do with legal action brought by
her estranged husband, Robert, over custody of their 1-year-old
She filed for divorce June 7 and was awarded custody of the girl, but
Robert took Susan back three weeks later. He said Judy "kept the baby’s
home and person ‘in a filthy state’ " and neglected the girl "to
associate with other men." A custody hearing was scheduled for Aug. 9
and Judy was hoping to find a job to show that she was a good mother.
"Judy was not the Hollywood type at all," Betty said. "She and I were
like sisters. She was going to get a job in a dime store to prove she
was worthy of her child."
Judith Ann (Vanhorn) Dull never made that custody hearing. On the
afternoon of July 29, 1957, a photographer named Johnny Glinn came to
the apartment and asked for Lynn. She wasn’t home, but Glinn noticed
some of Judy’s pictures and asked about hiring her instead. Glinn made
an appointment to pick up Judy at 2 p.m. on Aug. 1, 1957, offering to
pay $40 ($286.61 USD 2006) for two hours of modeling.
Betty thought Glinn was creepy for following Judy around the apartment
the day they left on the photo shoot. "I knew there was something odd
about the man," she said. "He said he wanted to shoot pinup pictures.
Yet he told her to bring a selection of street outfits, which she did."
She became worried when Judy didn’t return and called Glinn’s phone
number, and was even more concerned when it turned out to be a machine
shop (he actually lived at 5924 Melrose). The next day, she reported Judy’s disappearance to deputies at the West Hollywood sheriff’s station.
But by then Judy was dead and buried in a shallow grave 4 1/2 miles
west of Indio, 100 feet off Highway 60/70. Glinn eventually took
detectives to the site. His real name: Harvey Murray Glatman.
To be continued.