Paul V. Coates – Confidential File, Feb. 13, 1960

Feb. 13, 1960, Mirror Cover

Mash Notes and Comment

Paul Coates    "Dear Mr. Coates:

    "I would like a little information concerning one of your television programs. 

    "Did you, or didn't you, interview Senator Kennedy some time ago and did he say that he wore a toupee?

    "Did he also say that he manufactures them and expects to pay for his campaign from what he earns in the business?

    "I made this statement to a friend of mine and she repeated it to her friend, who is up in the air about it.

    "She says that somebody started this rumor to make it tough for the Senator.

    "If I made a mistake I wish to correct it because I meant no harm.  I like Senator Kennedy very much and certainly wouldn't tell something that wasn't true.

    "Please tell me if I am right."  (Signed) Mrs. Mary Osborne, Pomona.

    –It's his own hair, lady.  Nobody would dare make a toupee like that.

::

Feb. 13, 1960, Finch Trial     (Press Release)  "Actress Phyllis Standish overheard that if there is anything a nonconformist hates worse than a conformist, it is another nonconformist who doesn't conform to the prevailing standards of nonconformity!"  (Signed) Larry E. Levin & Associates, 1356 N Vine St., Hollywood.

    –That's what you get for eavesdropping, Big Ears!

::

Feb. 13, 1960, Finch Trial     (Form Letter)  "Dear Subscriber:
    "Suspense!  It's important in a novel, exciting in a movie — but only confusing when it comes to bookkeeping. 

    "Two months ago we entered your subscription to Harper's and billed you accordingly.  But your bill, at this writing, remains unpaid.

    "Strange things can happen to old bills.  They make convenient bookmarks.  Folded, they balance an unsteady coffee table.  The backs are ideal for hasty notes to the mailman.

    "In the event your first bill was misplaced, we are enclosing another with this letter.

    "We would appreciate receiving your remittance.  The suspense is killing our bookkeeper."  (Signed) John Jay Hughes, Circulation Director, Harper's Magazine, New York City.

    –Well, don't try to pin the rap on me.  If I didn't kill him, some other deadbeat would.

::

    (From Letter) "A gentleman's guide to being a gentleman.

    "That's what this letter is.  And in it you'll also find an opportunity to subscribe to America's most exciting magazine for gentlemen at a positively roguish price:  one-half off.

    "The magazine?  What else but Esquire? . . ."  (Signed) Esquire Magazine, Boulder, Colo.
   
    –You call yourselves gentlemen?  That poor bookkeeper at Harper's — his body isn't even cold yet, and you're over here romancing me.

::

    "Dear Paul Coates,

    "My name is Oscar.  I'm an 11-year-old dog.

    "Can you do something for me?  I want to go to Africa.  I haven't got the money and it's too far to swim or walk.

    "My master Capt. E.R. Tobias, is in the Army, on his way to Africa now.  His wife is with him.  The Army wouldn't let me go on a jet with them, I can go on regular planes or boats.

    "That's my story.  All I want is to surprise my master.  I know he's grieving for me.  Not as much as I am grieving for him, though.

    "I can't eat.  I can't sleep.  I just sit at the front door and watch and hope.  Can you help me get to Africa?"  (Signed) Oscar, an 11-year-old dog.  c/o Mrs. F.Kammer, Capt. Tobias' mother, 8840 S Walnut Way, Whittier.

    –Oscar, that's a nice letter.  Good grasp of  syntax. And think of it — you're only 11 years old!
   

Posted in #courts, Columnists, Front Pages, Homicide, Paul Coates | Comments Off on Paul V. Coates – Confidential File, Feb. 13, 1960

UCLA Students Honor John Belushi

image

image

image 

Feb. 13, 1980: John Belushi comes to UCLA to receive the Jack Benny Memorial Award for Excellence in Entertainment. Asked if he would do serious movie roles, Belushi replies: "These days, people need comedy."

Posted in broadcasting, Film, Hollywood, Television | Comments Off on UCLA Students Honor John Belushi

A Kinder, Simpler Time Dept.: Your Movie Columnist

Feb. 13, 1951, Hedda Hopper 

Feb. 13, 1951: Edith Head, the Paramount designer, says: "I don't know why I'm so happy these days unless it's because I've found a waist smaller than Veronica Lake's." The 21 1/2-inch waist belongs to Jan Sterling, Hedda Hopper reports.

July 8, 1973, Veronica Lake

July 8, 1973: Veronica Lake dies of acute hepatitis at the age of 51.

July 8, 1973, Veronica Lake

Posted in Columnists, Film, Hollywood, Obituaries | Comments Off on A Kinder, Simpler Time Dept.: Your Movie Columnist

Home-Schooler Goes to Jail

July 22, 1959, Finch Case 
Photograph by John Malmin / Los Angeles Times

July 21, 1959: Dr. R. Bernard Finch escorts police and reporters in a tour of the crime scene in West Covina. 

Feb. 13, 1960, Finch Trial

Newsmen at the courtroom door peep through a crack to get details on Dr. R. Bernard Finch and co-defendant Carole Tregoff.

Feb. 13, 1960, Home-School

"Dr. Shinn claims public school instruction is based on the lowest common denominator."

Feb. 13, 1960, Rita Moreno

Feb. 13, 1960: Actress Rita Moreno is injured when her car spins out at 2222 Laurel Canyon Blvd. and hits a tree. She throws pillows and curses at reporters and photographers when she is taken to Hollywood Receiving Hospital.

Posted in #courts, Education, Film, Hollywood | Comments Off on Home-Schooler Goes to Jail

New Studio Signs Stars, Plans Complex Near Culver City

Feb. 13, 1920, Briggs 
“Oh, Man!” by Clare Briggs.

Feb. 13, 1920, Movies

Location sleuth, Feb. 13, 1920: “A section of Chinatown was practically remodeled early this week to conform to the exigencies of ‘The Heart of a Child,' from Frank Danby's novel, which is Nazimova's current Metro vehicle. The Chinese were bewildered by the changes made in their haunts by motion picture painters and carpenters.” And Sam Goldwyn says Maurice Maeterlinck is coming to work in the movies. Zasu Pitts’ contract of $1,000 a week translates to $10659.60, USD 2008.

Posted in art and artists, Comics, Film, Hollywood | Comments Off on New Studio Signs Stars, Plans Complex Near Culver City

Family Searches for Artist Driven Insane by Painting Frescoes

Feb. 13, 1910, Valentine's Day

The Times’ editorializes on Valentine’s Day, of which it is much in favor.  “Think back — think away back along the track of the wild years to the day when you sent your first valentine."

Feb. 13, 1910, Fresco Painter

Feb. 13, 1910: Fresco painter Wick Hennen of 644 Maple Avenue has vanished after going insane from looking at ceilings all day, his family says. The Times never reported anything further, as far as I can tell …  And Michael McShean, "a timid and weakened tuberculosis sufferer," committed suicide after losing his investment in a cigar stand at 5th and Ruth streets, according to testimony in the fraud trial of Dolph M. Greene.

Posted in #courts, art and artists | Comments Off on Family Searches for Artist Driven Insane by Painting Frescoes

Matt Weinstock, Feb. 12, 1960

Feb. 12, 1960, Mirror

Hollywood Countdown

Matt Weinstock     Lt. Gen. James M. Gavin, retired Army chief of research and development, related wryly yesterday that MGM almost launched the nation's first satellite in 1957.

    Producer Andy Stone, he recalled, was bringing out a movie about missiles at the time.  Knowing the military hoped to put a satellite in orbit as part of the IGY program and realizing what a great publicity buildup it would be for his film, Stone got busy.

    He approached the Army, the Air Force, then Dr. William H. Pickering told him there was one man in the country who'd do this for good old MGM — Dr. Wernher von Braun at Redstone Arsenal.

    "How much would it cost?"  Stone asked.

    "About $10,000,000," Pickering replied.

image     Stone grabbed a phone and called his MGM chieftains.  They said no.

::

    IT HAS BEEN a prolific week for inadvertence and byplay, public speaking division.

    As the Rev. Dan Towler, former Ram fullback got up to acknowledge his appointment to the County Commission on Human Relations, a newsman pointed to the step to the raised podium and said, "Be careful somebody doesn't go over you, reverend."  Dan replied, "They may go around me but they won't go over me."

    Then there was the fluff at the press conference for Sen. Hubert Humphrey.  A questioner called him "Mr. Kennedy" then, trying to correct himself, "Sen. Kennedy."

    Finally there was the exchange between Al Terrence, president of the Eastside Boy's Club, and Sheriff Pete Pitchess when Terrance was given a scroll for his work in youth welfare.  As Pitchess arrived late Terrence needled, "I wonder how our sheriff made out with the mayor of Chicago about that police job back there.  Did you get it, Pete?"  "No, Al," Pete retorted, "but I recommended Bill Parker for the job."

::


    HARRY OLIVER
retells on his Almanac page in Desert magazine one of Abe Lincoln's favorite stories.

    A tanner needed an emblem to proclaim the nature of his business and decided to hang a calf's tail outside his door.  One day the tanner saw a dignified stranger staring intently at the tail.  After a  while he could stand the suspense no longer.  He went out and asked if the stranger wanted to buy leather or perhaps sell hides.

    "No," the stranger replied in frowning contemplation.

    "Then who are you?"  the tanner pursued.

    "I am a philosopher, sir," the stranger said, "and although I have been standing here for half an hour I still can't make out how that calf got through that hole."

::


    ONE OF THE
other papers had a situation-wanted ad for a "public relations engineer" and Joe Weston feels that the ultimate has been reached.  Joe still calls himself a press agent, the original term.  Others, however, refer to themselves as publicity directors, public relations counselors, media guidance experts, communications advisers, press consultants — and now the PR engineer.  Wonder if they'll wear those funny caps, like locomotive engineers.

::

    SECURITY
Some weary wise, lonesome
    guys, compromise
For apple pies, family ties,
    lullabies.
   MARGARET MAHAN

::


    MISCELLANY —
A final literary switch is achieved in Stuart James' gamey new novel, "Jack the Ripper."  It is stated to be "based on the original screen play by Jimmy Songster" . . . Remember when the tanker Angelo Petri, with a cargo of 2.5 million gallons of wine, was reported wallowing helplessly in a storm off San Francisco?  Well, no truth to the rumor that volunteer groups on Skid Row had formed flotsam and jetsam committees and stood ready to rush to the scene . . . Mark Larkin, press representative for Mary Pickford and Doug Fairbanks Sr. in Hollywood's good old days, is back in town to stay.  He explains, "I went to New York on a six-weeks job and stayed 20 years."

   

Feb. 12, 1960, Abby

 
Posted in City Hall, Columnists, Matt Weinstock | Comments Off on Matt Weinstock, Feb. 12, 1960

Paul V. Coates – Confidential File, Feb. 12, 1960

Feb. 12, 1960, Mirror Cover 

If Jack Paar is remembered at all, it’s for walking off the “Tonight” show (yes, he returned). From watching him as a kid, I remember him as being urbane but volatile – a curious combination.

Feb. 11, 1960, Hex

Minnie, 83, and Young Neighbor, 75, Feuding

Paul Coates    (News item)  DETROIT, Feb. 11- When 83-year-old Mrs. Minnie Gilland decided her "young" 75-year-old neighbor, Mrs. Mary Donaldson, was trying to "witch" away her husband, she knew exactly what to do.  She painted a "hex" sign- of tar and chicken feathers- on Mrs. Donaldson's house. A local judge knew what to do, too.  He found her guilty of destroying property.

    While the rest of you were idly standing in line for tickets to the Finch trial yesterday, I was busy getting the facts on another reported love triangle.

    To wit, that rumored affaire d'amour between Mary Donaldson and Minnie Gilland's husband.

    And I can tell you now, there isn't a thing to it.

    I telephoned Mrs. Donaldson in Detroit last night.

    "This is The Mirror News in Hollywood calling," I explained.  (Whenever I phone anybody long-distance I always tell them I'm calling from Hollywood.  Everybody's heard of Hollywood.  But how many out-of-towners have heard of Los Angeles?)

    "From Hollywood?" she gasped.  "What do you want with me?"

Feb. 12, 1960, Jack Paar     I explained that Minnie Gilland's accusations against her had been printed here, and the interests of honest journalism would be served if she would tell me her side of the story.

    "Oh," she commented.  Then she added:  "Frankly, I don't need any more publicity about it.  I wouldn't have that woman's husband."

    "Then," I probed gently, "it was all just nasty neighborhood gossip?"

    "Gossip?"  Mrs. Donaldson cried.  "Who was gossiping?  It was just that woman.  She was the only one who was saying things.

    "The neighbors," she added.  "They're all on my side."

    "You never did anything to arouse her suspicions?"  I asked.

    Mrs. Donaldson cleared her throat.  "Sir, I'm an honorable woman.  The only association I have with that woman's husband is I buy my coal from him.  He's a coal-man.  But all he does is pour it into the bin.  From outside the house, I do my own shoveling.

    "Of course," she added after a pause, "I've given him a meal a few times.  But everybody in the neighborhood does.  That woman won't even cook for her husband.  He'd starve if we didn't feed him."

Feb. 12, 1960, Finch Trial     "Do you think," I asked, "that Mrs. Gilland might have misinterpreted these little acts of neighborliness and put the hex on you? . . ."

    "Put the hex on me?"  Mrs. Donaldson interrupted.  "She didn't put any hex on me.  She claims that I put one on her to get her husband away from her.  She told the judge that was why she put that big circle of tar and feathers on my house.  To get rid of the hex that I put on HER.
   
    "Me!" she said.  "I don't even believe in hexes."

    There was, but only for a moment, silence.  Then Mrs. Donaldson continued:

    "And another thing.  That woman told the papers that she was 83 years old.  More like 85 and 90, if you ask me.  Married to a man in his 60s.  Imagine that!  She says he's her second husband, but I say he's her third."

Indelicate Question

    "The papers," I inserted gingerly, "quoted your age as 75.  Is that right?"

    "Well, I don't show my age.  At least, that's what everyone says."

    "May I ask you an indelicate question, Mrs. Donaldson?"

    "You may try,"   she said.

    "Do you," I said, "have any romantic interests at present?"

    "Sir,"  she said, "I'm 75 years old.  I'm a widow.  When you're my age, you don't think of things like that.  That's why I can't understand what's gotten into that woman."

    By this time, I had the situation pretty well sized up.  I thanked Mrs. Donaldson.  I hung up satisfied that I had protected the sanctity of one American home.

    And now that that's out of the way, I've got this guy saving my place in line at the Finch trial and I'm open to any reasonable offers.  Do I hear $5?   
   

Posted in #courts, broadcasting, Columnists, Front Pages, Homicide, Paul Coates, Television | 1 Comment

Jim Murray – Requiem for a Buddy

Feb. 12, 1980, Jim Murray
Feb. 12, 1980, Jim Murray 

Feb. 12, 1980: A Jim Murray turn of phrase, “When you talk about love affairs, you start with theirs. They made Romeo and Juliet look like enemies.”

Posted in Columnists, Sports | 1 Comment

A Kinder, Simpler Time Dept.: Your Movie Columnist

Feb. 12, 1950, Hedda Hopper

Feb. 12, 1950, Hedda Hopper

Feb. 12, 1950: William Holden tells Hedda Hopper, "It's up to the producers. You know stars are made by them before they're made by the public. And stars are broken by producers before they're broken by the public. Thus it's a common thing for the public to be asking for stars about whom the producers have entirely forgotten."

Posted in Columnists, Film, Hollywood | Comments Off on A Kinder, Simpler Time Dept.: Your Movie Columnist

Movie Star Mystery Photo


      Feb. 8, 2010, Mystery Photo
Los Angeles Times file photo

 
Update: Virtually everyone recognized our mystery guest as Louise Beavers.

Oct. 27, 1962, Louise Beavers

Oct. 27, 1962: Louise Beavers dies at the age of 60.

Nov. 2, 1962, Louise Beavers

 
Nov. 2, 1962: Services for Louise Beavers include her favorite gospel song, “City Called Heaven,” and her favorite Scripture, Psalm 91

Nov. 26, 1974, Louise Beavers
After her death, Beavers was the subject of several articles in The Times examining the portrayal of African Americans in movies, including this Nov. 26, 1974, piece by J.K. Obatala. In 1976, Beavers was posthumously inducted into the Black Film-Makers Hall of Fame in Oakland.

Just a reminder on how this works: I post the mystery photo on Monday and reveal the answer on Friday … or on Saturday if I have a hard time picking only five pictures; sometimes it's difficult to choose. To keep the mystery photo from getting lost in the other entries, I move it from Monday to Tuesday to Wednesday, etc., adding a photo every day.

I have to approve all comments, so if your guess is posted immediately, that means you're wrong. (And if a wrong guess has already been submitted by someone else, there's no point in submitting it again).

If you're right, you will have to wait until Friday. There's no need to submit your guess five times. Once is enough. The only reward is bragging rights. 

The answer to last week's mystery star: Blossom Seeley and Benny Fields.

Feb. 9, 2010, Mystery Photo  Los Angeles Times file photo

Update: The caption information on the back of the photo, stamped Oct. 15, 1950, says, “Unimpressed by the celebrated glamour of his opponent, many Hollywood celebrities are working energetically to elect Rep. Richard Nixon to the United States Senate. Here are a trio who have teamed up to work in the Nixon-for-Senator campaign: Irene Dunne, Louise Beavers and Hedda Hopper.”

Wow! Nearly everybody identified our mystery guest, too many folks to list everybody’s name. Here’s another picture of our mystery guest with two (not very) mysterious companions. Aren't the hats great?

Feb. 10, 2010, Mystery Photo

Los Angeles Times file photo

Update: Louise Beavers and Postmaster Mary D. Briggs in an undated photo.

Daily Mirror readers are certainly sharp! Everybody recognized yesterday’s (not very) mysterious companions. Today’s mystery companion may be a little more difficult. 

Feb. 11, 2010, Mystery Photo

Los Angeles Times file photo

Update: Louise Beavers, Ann Sheridan and an unidentified actor (suggestions include Clinton Sundberg and Dick Ross) in “Good Sam,” Sept. 15, 1948.

And here’s our mystery guest with two more mysterious companions.  So far nobody has identified yesterday’s mystery companion – but she’s tough.

Feb. 12, 2010, Mystery Photo

Los Angeles Times file photo

Update: Louise Beavers in “Beulah,” with Jane Frazee, left, David Bruce, center, and Stuffy Singer.

 
Posted in Film, Hollywood, Mystery Photo, Photography | 76 Comments

Confronted With Recording, Finch Says He Wouldn’t Lie

Carole Tregoff, July 22, 1959
Photograph by John Malmin / Los Angeles Times

July 22, 1959: Carole Tregoff enters a detectives' office for more questioning in the death of Barbara Jean Finch.

Feb. 12, 1960, Finch Trial

Feb. 12, 1960, Finch Trial

Feb. 12, 1960, Finch Trial

Feb. 12, 1960, Finch Trial

Feb. 12, 1960, Cocoanut Grove

Hey, it’s Lena Horne at the Cocoanut Grove. Wouldn’t it be great to visit the Ambassador Hotel? Oh wait, we let L.A. Unified tear it down.

image

And then there’s the mystery of the guns found in a trash barrel outside Rondelli’s after the killing of Jack “the Enforcer” Whalen.

Feb. 12, 1960, Chavez Ravine

Feb. 12, 1960: The Times’ Frank Finch reports that Dodger Stadium will be symmetrical … and Bill Veeck predicts major league ball in Tokyo, Caracas, Honolulu and Mexico City.

Posted in #courts, Dodgers, Front Pages, Homicide, Sports | Comments Off on Confronted With Recording, Finch Says He Wouldn’t Lie

Former Minister Accused of Abuse

Feb. 12, 1920, Briggs “Wonder What a Twenty-Two Months-Old Baby Thinks About?” by Clare Briggs.

 Feb. 12, 1920, Minister 

 

Feb. 12, 1920: Walter H. Evans, a former Episcopal minister, is accused of extreme cruelty by his wife, who said she even wrote his sermons for him because he was so lazy. 

Posted in #courts, Comics, Religion | Comments Off on Former Minister Accused of Abuse

A Humiliating Night in Jail

Feb. 12, 1910, Jail 
 
Feb. 12, 1910: John L. Grant and his wife, Margie, are in jail on charges of obtaining money under false pretenses, accused of selling their five-year lease and the furniture in a rooming house at 1401 N. Winfield St. when their rent agreement prohibited transferring the lease.  Margie Grant may have been a delicate soul (she fainted at the sight of handcuffs) but she described an unpleasant night at the city jail.

Posted in #courts, LAPD | Comments Off on A Humiliating Night in Jail

Matt Weinstock, Feb. 11, 1960

 
Feb. 11, 1960, Peanuts
image

A Visit From Ptex

Matt Weinstock     After an absence of several years, Tex, or as he prefers to spell it, Ptex, dropped in the other day to say hello.  He brought with him, as he usually does, a great idea.

    "They're always giving these big banquets for political and civic leaders," he said, "how about a testimonial dinner for me?  I think I deserve one.  I'm the only real complete failure in the world."

    Ptex, a huge, jovial gentleman with a gray goatee, didn't come by this distinction without considerable strain.  He has been everywhere, done everything.  He has worked on newspapers, taught school, promoted weird schemes, advised men in high places, helped plot revolutions and, he admits frankly, washed dishes professionally and recently.

    Now at last, he said, he wants to do something big.  With the money he would get from the testimonial dinner, say $3,000 or $4,000, he would charter a "cotton picking yacht" at Balboa and run a cruise for 30 or 40 interested persons through the Panama Canal to Yucatan.  He figures $1,000 each would be about right.  And he has his mate's papers, you know.

image     "YUCATAN,"
he sighed dreamily, "that's the place!"  There's a house in the town of Progresso, on the Mexican coast, he said, that could be used as a base for trips to the Mayan ruins.  He would, of course, act as guide for the persons fortunate enough to make the trip. 

    Meanwhile, I asked, how are things?

    Well sir, he'd just been over to the blood bank and picked up $4.  He pulled up his sleeves to show the bit of gauze Scotch-taped to the inside of the bend in his arm.  And he was eating, not good but all right, at the missions.

    And after the $4 was gone?

    "If I can't make it on four bucks," he said confidently, "I can't make it!"

    ::
    YESTERDAY a dispatch from Moscow reported that M. Agrest, Soviet scientist, was claiming that visitors from outer space landed in the Libyan Desert at least 1 million years ago and, failing to convey their wisdom to the stupid earth people, blew up the wicked cities of Sodom and Gomorrah with their excess nuclear fuel before blasting off.

    Tonight Reinhold Schmidt, Bakersfield grain buyer, is scheduled to speak in Pasadena on "My Recent Trips in Spacecraft" if, a press release states, "he returns in time from a flight to the Great Pyramid of Gizeh in Egypt,"  Underneath which, he claims that his friends on Saturn have told him, an ancient space shift is buried.

    A skeptical photog placed these two items on my typewriter with a plaintive note, "Tell me it's so — I want to believe."  I have recommended to his boss that he be taken off the Finch trial.  Obviously he has been there too long and his imagination's gone.

::


    TO ALL THE
people who turned and laughed at seeing three station wagons loaded with youngsters, skis, toboggans, WHEEL CHAIRS and CRUTCHES on San Berdoo Freeway the other day, let Kay Wannell explain.  They were cerebral palsy youngsters who can hardly stand, going to the mountains to enjoy the snow . . . Speaking of which, singer Johnny O'Keefe, here from Australia to record for Liberty, was asked what he'd like to see.  Disneyland?  Nope.  Snow.  There isn't any in Sydney.  He was taken to Big Bear.

::


    CENT-ENARIAN
He lived to be
    one hundred five.
Just why he didn't know.
I'll tell you why he
    stayed alive-
He stashed away his dough.
        JOSEPH P. KRENGEL

::


    AT RANDOM —
How ironical can things get?  At the time fire swept through his apparel plant at 825 S Los Angeles St., Sunday, causing $25,000 damage, owner A.Blum was at home trying to fire up his barbecue.  He had trouble getting it lit . . . Mrs. Clinton Tompkins blinked as she passed an El Monte market that gives trading stamps.  A letter had been deleted from a  sign so that it seemed to offer "Blue Hip."  Probably a cut of meat from the blue hippopotami which have been known to roam the saloons.

Feb. 11, 1960, Abby 

 
Posted in Caryl Chessman, Columnists, Comics, Matt Weinstock, UFOs | Comments Off on Matt Weinstock, Feb. 11, 1960

Paul V. Coates – Confidential File, Feb. 11, 1960

 
Feb. 11, 1960, Mirror Cover

A Woman Pays, Pays and Pays for Nothing

Paul Coates    The word is blackmail, and you don't know what it means until it happens to you.

    Mrs. Anita Roddy-Eden Sutton said it happened to her on the third day following her marriage to actor John Sutton.  That was Feb. 24, 1957.

    She and Sutton were honeymooning at the St. Regis in New York when the phone in their suite rang.

    She lifted the receiver and the man's voice told her, "Good morning , Mrs. Manville.  How do you like being a bigamist?"  That was all the man said.  Then the phone went dead.

    "Who was that calling?"  the actor asked his bride.

    "Nobody," she stammered.  "It was a wrong number."

    But it wasn't.  It was a very right number.  Before her marriage to Sutton, Anita Roddy-Eden had been Tommy Manville's ninth wife.  Their 3 1/2 year union — which had been her first — ended in a Reno divorce in 1955.

Feb. 11, 1960, Finch Trial     Anita hinted there were some possible irregularities.  That's what worried the new Mrs. Sutton.  There was, for example, the possibility that she hadn't fulfilled the six-week Nevada residence requirement — but she had stated in court at the time that she had.  There was a chance that she was guilty of perjury, as well as bigamy.

    This, the mysterious caller knew.  And he told her so when he phoned her again that night.

    "How would you like Mr. Sutton to find out?" he asked.

    The thought terrified her.  The caller apparently knew it would because he set a $10,000 price tag on his silence.  Mrs. Sutton laughed uneasily and asked where she would get that kind of money.  But the caller was too familiar with her financial status to fall for her bluff.  "You've got it," he said.

    She did.  And after a few more persuasive phone calls in the next couple of days, she stuck it in an envelope, wrote — according to instructions — the name "Mr. Forest" on it and left it at the hotel desk.

    She had been assured — as all blackmail victims are — that this would be the only payment she would be required to make. 

    Even at the price, she figured that she was getting off cheap, if the silence would save her new marriage and keep her out of trouble with the Nevada authorities.

Feb. 11, 1960, Finch Trial     Yesterday, Mrs. Sutton recalled for me the strange emotions that tore her after that first $10,000 payment.

    "Whoever was blackmailing me knew an awful lot about me," she said.  "That's what bothered me most.  I'd look at my friends and wonder if they were implicated."

    Three months passed before the blackmailers contacted her again.  They wanted another ten grand.  After some persuasion, she paid a second time.

    But this didn't stop them.  They hit her again in July of '57 for $5,000 more, and in August twice, for $1,000 each time.  Total $27,000.

    "By then," she told me yesterday, "it was driving me half-crazy.  I'd devise little schemes to try to trip them up, to catch them.  But I never succeeded.  The only thing that stopped them was the fact that my husband and I went out of the country."

    The Suttons eventually returned to the U.S. and as the months passed her fears that the blackmailers would reappear diminished.  "Sometimes I'd go days, weeks, without thinking about them."

    But then, last December, her husband opened a note addressed to her which was mixed among a batch of Christmas cards.

    It was from the blackmailers, announcing that they were back — and when John Sutton confronted his wife with it she broke down and told him the whole story.

Secret in Public Domain

    Also the press.  That apparently cost her the sympathy of the district attorney in Reno, William J. Raggio.  He said inspection of the records failed to back up her statement of blackmail and irregularities in the divorce.

    "I can only assume her statement is insincere and issued for the purpose of obtaining publicity," he said, "especially in view of the fact the statements have been made to the press rather than to the officials concerned."

    In any event, Mrs. Sutton's $27,000 secret wasn't a secret anymore.

    "If you had the choice again . . .?"  I started.

    "If I had the choice again, I don't know," she answered.  "I guess I was a fool to pay them the $27,000.

    "But," Anita Roddy-Eden Sutton added, "it bought me three years of silence.  And they were very happy years."

  

Posted in #courts, Columnists, Front Pages, Homicide, Paul Coates | Comments Off on Paul V. Coates – Confidential File, Feb. 11, 1960

The Specials at the Whisky

Feb. 11, 1980, The Specials
Feb. 11, 1980, The Specials 

Feb. 11, 1980: The long-awaited merger of punk and reggae is message, mirth and mayhem, Richard Cromelin says.

Posted in Music, Nightclubs, Rock 'n' Roll | Comments Off on The Specials at the Whisky

A Kinder, Simpler Time Dept.: Your Movie Columnist

Feb. 11, 1949, Hedda Hopper 

Feb. 11, 1949: Wedding bells for Clark Gable and Joan Crawford? Hedda Hopper says no.

Posted in Columnists, Film, Hollywood | Comments Off on A Kinder, Simpler Time Dept.: Your Movie Columnist

Finch Shows How He Cracked Wife’s Skull

 Feb. 10, 1960, Bernard Finch, Carole Tregoff
Photograph by John Malmin / Los Angeles Times

Dr. R. Bernard Finch passes co-defendant Carole Tregoff while returning to his chair after a court recess.

Feb. 11, 1960, Finch Trial
Feb. 11, 1960, Finch Trial
Feb. 11, 1960, Finch Trial
Feb. 11, 1960, Finch Trial

Feb. 11, 1960, Finch Trial
Feb. 11, 1960, Sex Poll

The State Board of Education clears a Van Nuys teacher who was charged with immoral or unprofessional conduct after taking a sex poll of his physiology classes.

Feb. 11, 1960: The transcript of the testimony in the Finch case runs four additional pages. If there’s enough interest I’ll add it, otherwise I’ll omit it. Posting so much material on a daily basis is incredibly time-consuming. 

Posted in #courts, Education, Homicide | 3 Comments

Caring for Stolen Car

Feb. 11, 1920, Briggs

“When a Feller Needs a Friend,” by Clare Briggs. [Note: The issue of child labor is a rare departure for Briggs, who usually kept his material humorous—lrh].

Feb. 11, 1920, Car Theft

Feb. 11, 1920:  Roy Mitchell denies stealing a car. Notice that The Times identified him as a Negro, which was typical in newspapers of the era and was common into the 1940s.

Posted in #courts, art and artists, Comics | Comments Off on Caring for Stolen Car